Updated July 21, 2025 by Abigail Bass

We all have fond memories of favorite toys from long ago – or maybe not so long ago. 

Toys are reminders of a past where everything seemed magical and fun, conjuring up memories of Christmas morning or visits to exciting toy stores. But toys can also be things of the present as well; who doesn’t love playing a good board game with friends? 

You might even be a collector of comics, miniatures, or memorabilia. Whatever the case, Orlando is the perfect place for you with several unique toy stores for everyone. 

As long-time Orlando locals, we are here to help you find the best stores for bringing back cherished memories and inspiring new ones. Check out some of our favorite toy stores in the city that are all sure to bring out the inner child in everyone.

Here’s a list of our top 5 toy stores in Orlando

Key Takeaways

• POP US! Collectables and Toys
• Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes
• Gods & Monsters
• American Girl
• Once Upon a Toy
• Play like a Kid Again at Rosen Inn Lake Buena Vista

POP US! Collectables and Toys

An outlet mall has everything you can imagine, including a great selection of toy stores. And at Orlando International Premium Outlets, you can find endless toys you and your family will love at POP US! Collectables and Toys. 

POP US! is known for its collectable items based on modern pop culture. Fans of the widely popular Funko Pop toy line will love the store’s array of Pop! figures with characters from “Stranger Things”, “Despicable Me”, and the latest Disney films. 

But the store isn’t just for those looking to add to their Pop! collection. Visitors can also find classic games like Rubik’s Cubes, as well as card games for bringing the whole family together such as UNO and Monopoly Deal.

Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes

Fans of Harry Potter will surely be familiar with this famous toy shop from the beloved series, and they now have a chance to go there themselves. 

In The Wizarding World of Harry Potter at Universal Studios Florida is where you can find Weasleys’ Wizard Wheezes. Take a walk down the iconic Diagon Alley to this store, where you can find your very own Peruvian Instant Darkness Powder or Sneakoscope. 

If you or someone in your family isn’t a Harry Potter guru – no problem. All guests can still admire this fun, brightly colored emporium and enjoy climbing the staircases where toys stretch two stories high. 

Gods & Monsters

If comics are your thing, be sure to check out this Orlando hidden gem toy store with geeky goodness waiting to be discovered. 

All things fantasy, comic-book, sci-fi, and anime find their place at Gods & Monsters, with endless aisles of books, collectibles, and games. They even have a Mad Max-themed bar in the back called Vault 5421, where you can stop for a drink to take a break from browsing their huge collection. 

The best part about Gods & Monsters is its convenient location on Orlando’s International Drive. Visit the store website for hours, event details, and everything happening at “Orlando’s Nerd Hub”. 

American Girl

These classic dolls are every girl’s dream, and Orlando features one of the select few stores in the country. 

Located within The Florida Mall is Orlando’s American Girl store, a one-stop-shop for finding your next dream doll. Browse through dozens of beautiful collector dolls or create your own with a unique, personalized look from head to toe. 

Not only can you choose from a wide selection of dolls and accessories, you can also have a birthday party or schedule an afternoon tea with your doll right in the store. Visit the doll hair salon to give your American Girl doll a new look, or take her to the spa for some refreshing care.

Once Upon a Toy

In Disney Springs, there’s hardly a more fun place to go than this favorite toy shop. Once Upon a Toy is your ticket to a world of endless fun and childhood magic. 

They carry all sorts of Disney toys, action figures, and clothing, but what sets this store apart are the “build-your-own” stations. Design your very own lightsaber or Star Wars droid, or pick out pieces for a unique Mr. Potato Head. 

Before bringing home your newest toy finds, don’t forget to take advantage of the photo-ops outside the store. Snap a picture with a larger-than-life Mr. Potato Head or take your visit to infinity and beyond with a photo next to Buzz Lightyear.

Play like a Kid Again at Rosen Inn Lake Buena Vista

Come experience the fun of Orlando’s toy stores for yourself while staying at Rosen Inn Lake Buena Vista, a perfect family vacation hotel. 

Just moments from Disney Springs and all of Orlando’s famous theme parks, you are perfectly located to get the most toy-filled vacation possible. Plus, you can shop for even more Disney-themed toys and treasures at our mini-market. 

Book your stay today and reconnect with the wonder of being a kid again.